Rush has officially announced their ‘Rush 50’ anniversary collection, set for release on March 21, 2025. The band unveiled the news via social media, sharing a teaser video that showcased the album artwork, credited to their longtime collaborator Hugh Syme. Alongside the announcement, fans were given a link to pre-order the collection and a preview of the first track—a live version of “Garden Road.”
However, the announcement quickly sparked heated debates among fans. Many questioned whether the album artwork was genuinely crafted by Syme or if AI tools were involved. Some fans pointed to the design’s “overly symmetrical” and “artificial” feel as evidence, with comparisons drawn to Syme’s recent work with Dream Theater, which has also faced similar scrutiny. “Look at Hugh’s recent work with Dream Theater—that’s AI 100%. Items are out of place, too symmetrical, etc.,” one fan claimed.
The controversy deepened as fans expressed disappointment, believing the use of AI conflicted with Rush’s legacy of authentic artistic expression. “This is clearly AI art,” one commenter wrote. “Really disappointing coming from my favorite band that sings about art as expression, not market campaigns.” Another added, “It’s sad either way—either these bands don’t know he’s using AI, or they do and just don’t care.”
Yet, not everyone agreed with the accusations. Some fans defended Syme, emphasizing his long-standing relationship with Rush and his distinctive style that often embraces surreal, precise designs. A fan who previously worked with Syme noted, “He paints by hand in Photoshop—no AI involved.” Others argued that Rush wouldn’t jeopardize a 50-year creative partnership without reason.
The AI debate wasn’t the only point of contention. Many fans expressed frustration over the collection’s pricing and content. Critics labeled it an “overpriced compilation” lacking substantial new material. Some were disappointed by the absence of anniversary editions for albums like ‘Grace Under Pressure’ or ‘Power Windows.’ Others wished for fresh live recordings or remixes instead of recycled content.
Despite the backlash, ‘Rush 50’ promises to deliver exclusive content, including seven previously unreleased live tracks from the band’s early years and a 104-page hardcover book featuring artwork, rare photos, and liner notes by renowned rock journalists David Fricke and Philip Wilding. The collection will be available in five formats: Super Deluxe Edition, Rush Store Exclusive Super Deluxe Edition, 7-LP Deluxe Edition, 4-CD Deluxe Edition, and Digital Edition.
As of now, Rush has not issued any statements addressing the AI controversy.