American Idol’s Season 23 finale wasn’t just about crowning a winner—it was a night filled with emotion, gratitude, and powerful hometown pride. While Jamal Roberts took home the title, it was runner-up John Foster who gave viewers a moment to remember, both on stage and back home in Louisiana.
As part of the show’s cherished hometown tradition, the Top 3 finalists took a break from Hollywood to return to their roots. For John Foster, that meant a triumphant visit to Addis, Louisiana—where the local love was loud, proud, and unforgettable.
John’s day kicked off with a stop at his sister Presley’s elementary school, followed by an emotional pep rally at Brusly High, his alma mater. There, he shared words of encouragement with students: “If you want to lead a meaningful life and leave a lasting legacy, start by listening to your teachers.” As the marching band played and cheerleaders cheered, it was clear the small town was bursting with pride for their hometown star.
He later visited the Louisiana State Capitol, where he serenaded lawmakers with “Amazing Grace,” even slipping into Cajun French for a touching tribute. “I talk about Louisiana a lot,” he said with a smile, “but that’s because it’s who I am.” Governor Jeff Landry honored him with an executive order officially naming May 14 as John Foster Benoit Appreciation Day—a moment that truly captured the state’s admiration for the 18-year-old singer.
The festivities didn’t stop there. A parade rolled through town with John riding high atop a giant crawfish float (Louisiana style, of course), tossing beads and waving to fans. That night, the celebration continued with a free outdoor concert at Bayou Plaquemine Waterfront Park, where John arrived by boat to a crowd ready to cheer him on.
He performed a six-song set that included country favorites like “Don’t Rock the Jukebox,” “I Told You So,” and “Callin’ Baton Rouge.” But it was his soul-stirring original, “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” written in memory of his late friend Maggie Dunn, that stole the show. Fans were visibly moved, and even those who didn’t know the backstory could feel the weight of every lyric.
During the Idol finale, John also performed a stripped-down version of John Denver’s “Take Me Home, Country Roads” as a heartfelt tribute to his Louisiana roots—cementing his identity as not just a country singer, but a storyteller with something real to say.
Reflecting on the experience, John told WBRZ, “Even if I didn’t win, my hometown visit reminded me that I’ll always have a place in this industry. The love from Addis, Brusly, Plaquemine, and beyond has carried me every step of the way.”
Now, John is focused on promoting “Tell That Angel I Love Her” and diving into work on his debut album. “I think that song gives people a great idea of who I am—not just as a performer, but as a writer,” he told TV Insider. Studio time is calling, and he’s ready to create more original music that reflects his heart, heritage, and growth.
As for what’s next? A possible spot on Dancing With the Stars isn’t off the table. “I hadn’t thought about that,” he laughed. “But hey, it’s not a no!”
First, though, there’s one thing he’s most excited about. “I’ve really missed my dog,” he said with a grin. “I’m looking forward to getting back home and just being with him.”
He may not have taken the top spot, but John Foster left American Idol as a true winner—humble, heartfelt, and ready for what’s next.
