18-year-old John Foster brought his A-game to Sunday night’s (May 4) American Idol Top 10 episode, delivering a lively rendition of Bonnie Raitt’s “Something to Talk About.” This performance kicked off the show’s first-ever Ladies Night theme, where the Top 10 paid tribute to some of the most iconic female voices in music.
While John is known for his classic country style, he stepped out of his usual lane with this song choice. In a pre-performance clip, he shared a sweet moment with Miranda Lambert, this week’s mentor, revealing that she was his “first crush.”
“I was like, ‘Okay, I love you,’” Lambert said after Foster walked in with his cowboy hat and guitar. Despite his nerves, John admitted he had trouble even looking at her while singing. But Lambert made him feel at ease by singing along, creating a memorable connection that made the moment even more special.
John’s rendition of “Something to Talk About” was a hit, earning praise from both the audience and the judges. As one of the only country artists to make it past Hollywood Week, Foster continues to impress, even earning a spot on the iTunes country charts with his original song, “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” after his emotional Easter performance.
After his Bonnie Raitt cover, the judges couldn’t stop complimenting his growth.
“I feel like you are the one that has grown the most throughout this whole process,” said Carrie Underwood. “Every time you step on stage, you get more comfortable, connect with the audience more—I just love that.”
Luke Bryan added, “Your charisma meter is off the charts right now!” It’s clear John Foster’s star is shining brighter than ever.
