On April 28, 2025, American Idol lit up with nostalgia and raw emotion during its “Iconic American Idol Moments” episode—and 18-year-old John Foster stole the spotlight. The country singer from Addis, Louisiana, delivered a moving rendition of Randy Travis’s classic “I Told You So,” a song also famously covered by Carrie Underwood. With his warm, soulful voice and heartfelt delivery, Foster turned the stage into a moment country fans won’t soon forget.
Throughout Season 23, Foster has stood out for his deep-rooted love of traditional country music and his ability to make every song feel personal. Week after week, he’s connected with audiences and judges alike—not just with his voice, but with his vulnerability.
One of his most talked-about performances came earlier in the season, when he sang an original song titled “Tell That Angel I Love Her.” It was a tearful tribute to his late friend Maggie Dunn, who tragically passed away in a car accident on New Year’s Eve 2022. That performance left a lasting impression and proved Foster wasn’t just a great singer—he was a storyteller.
With “I Told You So,” Foster once again showed why he’s a fan favorite. His emotional depth, vocal control, and timeless sound reminded everyone that traditional country still has a powerful place on today’s stage. As the judges said, it wasn’t just a performance—it was a moment.
