The Season 23 finale of American Idol aired on May 18, 2025, with Jamal Roberts taking home the title. But for many viewers, it was 18-year-old John Foster from Addis, Louisiana, who stole the show — and their hearts. Even though he finished as the runner-up, it’s clear he won the love and support of nearly half the country.
The exciting three-hour finale was packed with standout performances from the Top 14 contestants and even a few unforgettable moments from the judges themselves. But it was John’s heartfelt performances and humble spirit that left a lasting impression.
Shortly after the show, John took to Instagram to thank his supporters and reflect on the whirlwind experience. Known for his smooth, soulful voice and old-school country charm, fans have often said he sounds like someone with decades of experience.
“Man, what a true blessing to share this Idol stage with so many incredible heroes,” he wrote. “I’m beyond thankful, and I can’t wait to keep making music for y’all as long as the good Lord lets me. Thank you from the bottom of my heart – times a million.”
A Finale Full of Heart
For his first finale performance, John chose the patriotic anthem “Courtesy of the Red, White and Blue,” encouraged by mentor Jelly Roll to pour everything he had into the moment. He followed it with a crowd-pleasing rendition of “Take Me Home, Country Roads,” which had both judges and the audience singing along.
After fellow finalist Breanna Nix was eliminated, John and Jamal went head-to-head for the final vote. For his last performance, John returned to a deeply personal place, singing his original song, “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” written in memory of his late friend Maggie Dunn. The emotional tribute brought many in the room to tears, including the judges.
Meanwhile, Jamal debuted his powerful original song “Heal,” calling it a prayer for those in pain.
A Moment of Speculation, But Nothing But Grace
As the final votes came in, fans noticed a brief moment that sparked conversation online — John seemed to glance at the results envelope just before Ryan Seacrest officially announced Jamal as the winner. Social media lit up with playful speculation:
“Did John Foster just peek at the card?”
“He looked like he saw the name before Ryan said anything!”
“Seacrest needs to face the contestants when announcing — John clearly saw it first!”
Regardless of how the moment played out, John handled it all with his signature grace and humility. His fans responded with overwhelming love and encouragement.
“John Foster, we’re so proud of you. You’re already a star.”
“Even though you didn’t win the title, you’ve won our hearts. Can’t wait for your music!”
“Addis, Louisiana has never been prouder!”
What’s Next for John Foster?
With his debut single already out and talk of a full album on the way, John Foster’s journey is only just beginning. Whether it’s on country radio, the concert stage, or in the studio, fans are excited to see where this rising star goes next.
As John himself says, “This is only the beginning. Don’t be discouraged. Keep going.”
And with that spirit, it’s clear we’ll be hearing from John Foster for years to come.
