This season of American Idol has been full of unforgettable performances, emotional stories, and jaw-dropping talent—but two finalists have truly stolen the spotlight. With just days left until the grand finale, fans are rallying behind their favorites: John Foster and Jamal Roberts. And let’s just say, opinions are fiercely divided.
At just 18 years old, John Foster from Addis, Louisiana, has become a fan favorite thanks to his classic country sound and calm, old-soul presence. Each week, he’s delivered heartfelt renditions that have made country lovers sit up and take notice. His standout performance of “I Told You So” had judges and fans alike praising his ability to make a well-known classic feel fresh and deeply emotional. John’s genuine humility and traditional style have won over longtime country fans—many of whom believe he’s the genre’s next big thing.
Then there’s Jamal Roberts, the 27-year-old PE teacher from Meridian, Mississippi, whose journey could be a hit song on its own. A proud #GirlDad and man of deep faith, Jamal’s powerful vocals and emotional storytelling have turned every stage appearance into something special. His recent performance of Fantasia’s “I Believe” gave everyone chills—and reminded audiences that Jamal isn’t just singing songs, he’s sharing his soul. And with the recent arrival of his newborn daughter, Gianna Grace, his Idol journey has become even more touching.
Both men have built passionate fan bases. John’s supporters are going all-out, flooding online votes and celebrating him as a future country star. Meanwhile, Jamal’s fans are cheering for the heart and honesty he brings to each note. His voice, his story, and his deep connection to gospel and R&B music make him unforgettable.
With the finale right around the corner, it’s anyone’s game. John may have a slight edge in sheer voting numbers, but Jamal’s emotional connection and powerful narrative give him just as much momentum. One thing’s for sure—American Idol hasn’t seen a showdown like this in years.
Whether you’re Team John or Team Jamal, you’re witnessing something special. Both finalists have already proven they have what it takes to succeed beyond the Idol stage. And no matter who takes home the title, their journeys have left a lasting impression.
Grab the popcorn—the finale is going to be one for the books.
