Jamal Roberts’ American Idol win was supposed to be a history-making celebration—the first Black male winner in more than 20 years. Instead, the spotlight has been partially stolen by unexpected controversy, much of it involving country superstar and Idol judge Carrie Underwood.
It all started just days after the finale. Carrie posted what seemed like a harmless photo from her farm: a baby lamb named “Jamal.” While she likely meant it as a lighthearted tribute, the post quickly sparked backlash. Many fans were not amused. Comments poured in accusing the gesture of being tone-deaf and dismissive. “You didn’t even hug him, but you name a lamb after him?” one user wrote. Another added, “This just feels wrong.”
But the lamb drama wasn’t the first red flag. Throughout the season, some viewers noticed Carrie’s cool attitude toward Jamal. While fellow judges Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan cheered him on and offered praise, Carrie’s reactions often felt distant—less applause, more criticism. One particular moment that stuck with fans? During his audition, Carrie told Jamal he needed more “swagger.” That word didn’t sit right with a lot of people—especially after seeing other contestants get glowing feedback for similar performances without any mention of “swag.”
Now, Jamal is opening up about it all. In a recent interview on The Morning Hustle, the 27-year-old Mississippi native addressed the tension with grace and honesty. When asked about Carrie’s vibe during the season, he kept it classy:
“Watching back, I saw she clapped and got on board… I don’t really know. I don’t have no comment there. Ring the bell.”
His response was calm—but telling. And when he talked about Luke Bryan, the shift in tone was obvious:
“Luke supported me 100%.”
It was clear where the love and support truly came from.
Even the show’s host acknowledged the awkwardness, admitting Carrie’s energy toward Jamal felt off from the start. Some fans agree—and they’ve taken things a step further, resurfacing past moments from Carrie’s career, including her performance at Donald Trump’s 2025 inauguration and an old sketch that appeared to mock healthcare policy. These moments have added fuel to ongoing discussions about Carrie’s image and connection with diverse audiences.
Behind the scenes, there are even whispers that Idol producers haven’t been thrilled with Carrie’s return as a judge. Some insiders say her presence has created tension, especially in a season that was meant to feel inclusive and forward-thinking.
Meanwhile, Jamal is staying focused. His debut single “Heal” is gaining serious momentum, and his humility and heart are winning fans across the country. He may not be addressing every headline, but his quiet strength speaks volumes.
Carrie’s chapter on Idol may be complicated, but Jamal’s story is just beginning—and he’s handling the spotlight like a true star.
