As American Idol gears up to crown its next winner, fans are already buzzing about what’s next—especially when it comes to Carrie Underwood’s future on the show.
This season, Carrie returned to the spotlight in a full-circle moment, joining Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan at the judges’ table 20 years after winning the competition herself. Alongside her fellow judges, she’s helped guide the Top 3—Breanna Nix, Jamal Roberts, and John Foster—toward the finale. Her presence has been both nostalgic and refreshing, with many fans loving her mix of heartfelt encouragement and honest critiques.
So, will Carrie be back for Season 24? That’s the big question.
In a recent interview with TVLine, showrunner and executive producer Megan Michaels Wolflick shared her thoughts on Carrie’s role this season:
“She really had to carve out her own role… and she definitely did that. I think she brought a nostalgia factor, and I also like that she brought a little criticism and constructive feedback, which is very much needed. She knows how hard she was pushed each week during her own season, and she’s brought that same passion.”
While Carrie hasn’t commented publicly about returning, fans are hopeful. Lionel and Luke—mainstays since 2018—also haven’t confirmed their return, but there’s no sign they’re stepping away.
As for the future of the show, Megan offered some encouraging news:
“American Idol is absolutely coming back. We already have thousands of submissions for next season… The momentum is strong. We’ll have more to share after the finale.”
Whether Carrie signs on again or not, her impact this season has been undeniable. And with Season 24 officially on the horizon, Idol fans have plenty to look forward to.