As American Idol Season 23 heads into its much-anticipated finale on Sunday, May 18, the competition is down to three standout finalists: Jamal Roberts, John Foster, and Breanna Nix. With just one more chance to win over America, the pressure is higher than ever—and the judges aren’t holding back with their thoughts.
Judge Luke Bryan didn’t mince words when asked who’s been leading the pack.
“My gut has told me Jamal’s been the front-runner all year,” Bryan shared in a post-show interview with PEOPLE.
The 48-year-old country star, known for his heartfelt and instinctive judging, praised 27-year-old Mississippi soul singer Jamal Roberts for his consistent standout performances. But he was quick to remind everyone: it’s still anyone’s game.
“You’ve got to stay focused. The music business never lets up,” Bryan warned.
A Final Three With Momentum
While Jamal might have the edge, Bryan also acknowledged the rising momentum of the other two finalists.
Breanna Nix, 25, has steadily climbed her way into the finale with quiet confidence and vocal strength.
“Every time Breanna gets through, we’re like, ‘There she goes again—making it happen,’” Bryan said.
And then there’s 18-year-old John Foster, whose emotional performances have made him a fan favorite, especially after his moving rendition of “Rainbow Connection.”
“John is gaining momentum,” Bryan added, hinting that the Louisiana teen could pull off a surprise win.
Lionel Richie: “It’s About Connection”
Judge Lionel Richie, ever the voice of wisdom, gave a dose of reality, pointing out that in the end, it’s not just about hitting the high notes.
“It’s an even playing field—but it comes down to popularity,” Richie said. “How many fans do they have that connect with them as people?”
With the finalists still singing covers, Richie stressed that emotional connection and relatability are what matter most right now—not just vocal technique.
“America is falling in love with the artist, not just the voice,” he added.
Carrie Underwood’s Advice: “This Is Star Boot Camp”
Season 4 champ Carrie Underwood knows the Idol journey better than anyone—and she didn’t sugarcoat how tough it’s been for this season’s Top 3.
“This season’s been more condensed. When I was on the show, we had a lot more time,” she explained. “So they’ve been sprinting from day one.”
Now, as the finalists return to their hometowns for emotional visits and final performances, Underwood offered a glimpse into what lies ahead.
“This is a taste of what a real artist’s life feels like. We call it ‘star boot camp’ for a reason—you learn fast, and you learn under pressure.”
With the finale just around the corner, one thing’s clear: each of these finalists brings something special to the table. Whether it’s Jamal’s soulful power, Breanna’s quiet strength, or John’s heartfelt authenticity, America has a tough choice to make.
And as Lionel said—it’s not just about who sings best. It’s about who the country’s ready to root for, long after the final note fades.
