Roger Waters describes his conflict with David Gilmour over the ‘Comfortably Numb’

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

Pink Floyd, a legendary classic rock band, has left an indelible mark on the music scene despite enduring considerable internal conflicts throughout their journey.

These tensions reached a significant point during the creation of their groundbreaking album, “The Wall,” featuring iconic songs such as “Comfortably Numb.”

The dispute over the rhythm track of “Comfortably Numb” saw bassist Roger Waters and guitarist David Gilmour at odds.

According to Waters, they initially made a rhythm track he loved, but Gilmour found it rhythmically imprecise. Gilmour then re-recorded the drum track and made other alterations.

“It’s probably one story where his memory and my memory would be almost exactly the same. We had made a rhythm track — so that would be the drums, bass, guitar, or whatever — and I loved it.

He thought it wasn’t precise enough rhythmically and recut the drum track and something else and said, ‘There, that’s better.’ And I listened to it and went, ‘No, it’s not. I hate that.’ So that’s all the disagreement was.

“And in the end, the track that is on the record, the first verse is from the version I liked, and the second verse is from the version he liked, then a bit of chorus from mine and a bit from his, so it was a negotiation and a compromise.”

This did not sit well with Waters, who openly expressed his dislike for the changes. It was a disagreement that led to a rare compromise, with the final recording blending both of their visions.

The first verse came from Waters’ preferred version, the second verse from Gilmour’s, and the chorus was a mix of both.

It’s interesting to note that despite “Comfortably Numb” becoming one of Pink Floyd’s signature songs, it did not chart in the UK or US.

The frequently misunderstood “Another Brick in the Wall (Part II)” from the same album, however, became the band’s only No. 1 hit in both countries.

The strains within the band were evident during the making of “The Wall.” Waters fired keyboardist Rick Wright and drummer Nick Mason was less involved due to his work on a solo album.

Nevertheless, the album was a triumph, characterized by its ambitious scope, memorable songs, and iconic album cover.

Despite the internal conflicts and acrimonious split, Pink Floyd managed to produce a highly successful project.

“The Wall” spent numerous weeks on the charts, achieved platinum certification, and has sold over 23 million copies.

This instance of conflict resolution and negotiation showcases how the clashing egos and mutual compromises within Pink Floyd contributed to the creation of their masterpieces.

Despite the tensions, they underscored the significance of collaboration, even amidst disagreement, shaping their unique legacy in the realm of classic rock.

Write A Comment