Nick Mason on “one of the worst” songs Roger Waters made

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

In the nascent days of Pink Floyd, the band was still finding its identity, navigating through the psychedelic landscape led by Syd Barrett’s innovative compositions.

As they evolved, Roger Waters emerged from the backdrop to steer the band into new territories, his songwriting prowess gradually eclipsing Barrett’s initial influence. Nick Mason, the drummer, once candidly criticized one of Waters’ early compositions, ‘Doctor Doctor’, considering it among the least impressive efforts from the band’s catalog.

Initially, Roger Waters was content playing a supporting role in ‘The Pink Floyd’, contributing to Barrett’s vision on tracks that would define the psychedelic era, such as ‘See Emily Play’.

However, Barrett’s deteriorating mental health led to his departure during the making of ‘A Saucerful of Secrets’, marking a pivotal shift in the band’s trajectory. Barrett’s exit and subsequent solo career left a bittersweet legacy, with his work both inspiring and haunting the band.

Waters’s early compositions, including ‘Take Up Thy Stethoscope and Walk’, were attempts to continue the band’s psychedelic journey. Despite Waters’s reluctance to overshadow Barrett’s legacy, he began exploring new lyrical and musical themes, gradually shifting towards what would become Pink Floyd’s signature sound.

‘Doctor Doctor’, while not achieving critical acclaim, served as a stepping stone towards more complex and textured compositions like ‘Set The Controls For The Heart of the Sun’. This song, in particular, showcased the band’s evolving sound, moving away from conventional psychedelic rock to embrace more experimental and progressive elements.

Mason’s reflection on ‘Doctor Doctor’ as a less-than-stellar piece underscores the band’s growth from psychedelic experimentation to the pioneers of progressive rock. This transition was further solidified with monumental works such as ‘Echoes’, and concept albums like ‘The Dark Side of the Moon’ and ‘The Wall’, which not only defined Pink Floyd’s legacy but also shaped the future of rock music.

The band’s journey from ‘Doctor Doctor’ to groundbreaking epics illustrates their willingness to evolve and push musical boundaries. While Mason may view ‘Doctor Doctor’ with a critical eye, its place in Pink Floyd’s history is a reminder of their humble beginnings and the creative leaps they made to become one of the most influential bands in rock history.

Write A Comment